• RankiaPro Europe
    • RankiaPro Spain
    • RankiaPro LATAM
    • RankiaPro Italy
SUBSCRIBE
Search
Close
  • Home
  • Insights
    EQUITIES
    EQUITIES
    FIXED INCOME
    FIXED INCOME
    ESG
    ESG
    INTERVIEWS
    INTERVIEWS
    MARKET OUTLOOK
    MARKET OUTLOOK
    ETF
    ETF

    Featured

    Cover-Silicon-Valley-Bank-bankruptcy
    Insights

    Silicon Valley Bank bankruptcy: the market reactions

  • News
    APPOINTMENTS
    APPOINTMENTS
    LAUNCHES
    LAUNCHES
    ASSET MANAGERS
    ASSET MANAGERS

    FEATURED

    cover-naim-abou-jaoude-ceo-candriam
    Asset Managers

    Candriam to acquire majority shareholding in Tristan Capital Partners: a leading european real estate manager

  • Magazine
  • Events
    RANKIA FUNDS EXPERIENCE
    EVENTS & CONFERENCE CALLS
    EVENTS & CONFERENCE CALLS
    RANKIAPRO MEETINGS
    RANKIAPRO MEETINGS
  • Podcast
  • MiFIDII Training
Menu
  • Home
  • Insights
    EQUITIES
    EQUITIES
    FIXED INCOME
    FIXED INCOME
    ESG
    ESG
    INTERVIEWS
    INTERVIEWS
    MARKET OUTLOOK
    MARKET OUTLOOK
    ETF
    ETF

    Featured

    Cover-Silicon-Valley-Bank-bankruptcy
    Insights

    Silicon Valley Bank bankruptcy: the market reactions

  • News
    APPOINTMENTS
    APPOINTMENTS
    LAUNCHES
    LAUNCHES
    ASSET MANAGERS
    ASSET MANAGERS

    FEATURED

    cover-naim-abou-jaoude-ceo-candriam
    Asset Managers

    Candriam to acquire majority shareholding in Tristan Capital Partners: a leading european real estate manager

  • Magazine
  • Events
    RANKIA FUNDS EXPERIENCE
    EVENTS & CONFERENCE CALLS
    EVENTS & CONFERENCE CALLS
    RANKIAPRO MEETINGS
    RANKIAPRO MEETINGS
  • Podcast
  • MiFIDII Training
Search
Close
Search
Close

Home | Can ‘passive’ thematic strategies really provide expert stock selection?

Can ‘passive’ thematic strategies really provide expert stock selection?

The first thing to note is that not all thematic ETF strategies are created equal.
RankiaPro Europe

2022/12/01

Por Chris Gannatti, Global Head of Research, WisdomTree

In our recent survey, 39% of European professional investors said they don’t believe passive strategies provide the expert stock selection required and, therefore, prefer actively managed thematic strategies1. The first thing to note is that not all thematic exchange-traded fund (ETF) strategies are created equal. The second is that some indices are actually very much built by experts with an approach that may well look very similar to the ‘active’ stock selection investors are familiar with. This is, indeed, the expert-driven approach that WisdomTree takes with its thematic range of ETFs.

In thematics, there are no easy selections

Some of the largest investment vehicles in the world track passive indices. If an investor is selecting an ETF tracking the FTSE 100 or the Euro STOXX 50, if there is familiarity with the Index, there is automatically familiarity with the strategy. These ‘beta’ type ETFs tended to see uptake first, and during the strong equity bull markets experienced since the Global Financial Crisis of 2008-09 they served investors very well.

But can one choose thematics so simply, basically picking ‘the topic’ based on the name of the strategy and being done with it? We would say unequivocally…no! But, before looking at theme selection, we should probably take a step back, for context, and consider the growth of thematic ETF strategies.

Inertia is important everywhere, particularly in investing

When you start out in investment management, a lot of the focus goes into thinking about how you can ‘win’ if you have the right idea or at least an idea that is better than that of your competition. With experience, you come to realize that, frequently, the best thing you can do is ‘act first.’ There are examples where the largest funds in particular categories are just those that were first-to-market.

To that end, across the European landscape of thematic strategies it can be clearly seen in Figure 1 that open-ended funds were there first, now having the benefit of simply having existed as options for about 20 years. On top of that, during much of that 20-year period, the ‘growth’ style of investing was very much in favour over the ‘value’ style.

What we find interesting in Figure 1 is that, more recently, exchange-traded fund usage within thematics has been growing quickly. Does this mean that we’ll soon see equal AUM in open-ended funds and ETFs? Probably not—we may have some years to go before that happens, if indeed it does. We do, however, hear certain ideas being repeated about why some investors are making this shift:

  1. Thematic ETFs frequently allow the investor to focus on a single thematic topic.
  2. They allow the investor the see underlying holdings each day.
  3. They can have lower fees than their actively managed peers.

Depending on what the rest of an investor’s portfolio looks like, and how they prefer to manage it, having the toolkit and option to use an array of ETFs as opposed to a single active approach can be helpful.

Figure 1: Open-ended funds have been available for roughly 20 years

Source: WisdomTree, Morningstar, Bloomberg. From 31 December 1999 to 31 August 2022. The list of Europe-Domiciled ETFs and Open-ended mutual funds has been compiled by WisdomTree as part of the WisdomTree’s own thematic classification. Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value.

Now, let’s go back to the topic of theme selection, which ties in nicely with one of the ideas we hear investors talk about: ‘thematic ETFs frequently allow the investor to focus on a single thematic topic’.

Figure 2 displays 36 underlying themes. Each dot represents a strategy that is seeking to generate returns of an investment in that theme. A wider vertical dispersion of the dots is telling us that within the same thematic topical group, we are seeing a wide range of performance. In ‘Sustainable Energy Production’ (furthest to the left), for instance, one strategy delivered around +30% for the first 8 months of 2022, whereas other strategies in this same topic group delivered returns worse than -20%.

At a minimum, Figure 2 tells us that the due diligence process that happens after a theme is selected, and before a specific fund is chosen, is of the utmost importance. While it would be impossible to know ahead of time which strategies would be the best or the worst, investors will want to be sure that they completely agree with the methodology being used to capture the theme.

Figure 2: Methodologies to capture themes can differ greatly, leading to large performance
dispersion

Source: WisdomTree, Morningstar, Bloomberg. From 31 December 2021 to 31 August 2022. Returns are calculated in US dollars on a monthly basis. Only funds live for the whole year-to-date period and classified in the indicated investment themes above are considered. Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value.

Conclusion: thematic methodologies represent a spectrum

There are thematic strategies that exist that are completely rules-based. Certain revenue measures are made, or natural-language artificial intelligence processing systems are run, and the companies are selected. While these strategies may have their moments in the sun performance-wise, in our opinion, these strategies are not going to be based upon the highest level of expertise and, ultimately, this is what investors should be expecting.

In contrast, there are strategies where third-party industry experts are doing something that looks very similar to active stock selection within the construction of thematic indices. For example, it’s worth considering whether an index being built with third-party experts whose business is based on understanding developments in the cloud computing space, will be able to build an index which is a more true reflection of that industry and ecosystem versus a generic index provider. Also, to what extent can that generic index provider identify the companies that are growing or have recently become publicly listed companies, and could be at the future of innovation within that industry. This approach seems to have limitations.

It’s true that a one-size fits all approach to thematic investing is always going to be hard to find and deliver but, looking under the bonnet, we can see that some thematic ETFs actually represent more expertise in the construction than might initially meet the eye. One thing is clear, not all thematic ETF strategies are created equal.

1Pan European Professional Investor Survey, September 2022, 600 respondents, conducted by Core Data Research.

  • ETF, Investment Strategies, Stocks, Thematics

Related Post

Luca Sibani_orizz

Why private market allocation should be higher?

COVER-2022

The best of our 2022 conference calls

COVER-GlobalMap Artemis

The US will lead in 2023; Asia could surprise…

NEWSLETTER
If you want to keep up to date with the latest news from the asset management industry and all our events, subscribe now to our newsletter.
Subscribe

Last Tweets

10h

🌤 The crucial role of resources in the energy transition debate

🔗#EnergyTransition #Resources #RankiaProEurope
...https://rankiapro.com/en/crucial-role-resources-energy-transition-debate/

10h

🗣️Change to @Amundi_ENG corporate governance

🔗 #Appoinment #Change #RankiaProEurope
...https://rankiapro.com/en/change-to-amundis-corporate-governance/

13h

🎙We introduce you to the new #AdvisoroftheMonth
João Martins, Senior Private Banker at ABANCA Portugal.
Don't miss
... his interview!

🔗#ProfessionaloftheMonth #RankiaProEurope
https://rankiapro.com/en/joao-martins-abanca-portugal-our-advisor-month/

14 Mar

🗣️ @Robeco launches Sustainable Senior Loan Fund

🔗#PrivateDebt #Sustainability #RankiaProEurope
...https://rankiapro.com/en/robeco-launches-sustainable-senior-loan-fund/

RankiaPro

  • Home
  • Insights
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Events
  • About us
Menu
  • Home
  • Insights
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Events
  • About us

Terms and uses

  • Cookies Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Menu
  • Cookies Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

Contact

  • [email protected]
  • (+34) 963 386 976
  • (+34) 640 308 023

Newsletter

If you want to keep up to date with the latest news from the asset management industry and all our events, subscribe now.

Subscribe

All rights reserved © 2003 – 2023 Rankia S.L.

RankiaPro

  • Home
  • Insights
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Events
  • About us
Menu
  • Home
  • Insights
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Events
  • About us

Terms and uses

  • Cookies Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Menu
  • Cookies Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

Contact

  • Email: [email protected]
  • Phone: 963 386 976 – 601 302 692

All rights reserved © 2003 – 2023 Rankia S.L.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide you the best experience on our website, we use technologies like our own and third-party cookies for analytical purposes and to store device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique identifiers on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent may adversely affect certain features and functions.

To learn more, please read our Cookie Policy and Privacy Statement.
Functionality or Personalisation Cookies Always active
These cookies are necessary for the website to function or for the unique purpose of transmitting a communication over an electronic communications network, and cannot be disabled on our systems. Usually they are set up to respond to actions made by you to receive services, such as adjusting your privacy preferences or filling out forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you to the presence of these cookies, but some parts of the website will not work. These cookies allow the website to provide better functionality and personalisation. They may be set by us or by third parties whose services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies some of our services will not work properly.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics Cookies
These cookies allow us to count traffic sources in order to measure and improve the performance of our website. Storage or technical access which is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing Cookies
These cookies may be site-wide, placed by our advertising partners. These third parties may use them to create a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. If you do not allow these cookies, you may receive less targeted advertising.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
Cookie Settings
{title} {title} {title}
  • RankiaPro Europe
    • RankiaPro Spain
    • RankiaPro LATAM
    • RankiaPro Italy
Menu
  • Home
  • Insights
    • Equities
    • ESG
    • ETF
    • Fixed Income
    • Interviews
    • Market Outlook
  • News
    • Appointments
    • Asset Managers
    • Launches
  • Magazine
  • Events
    • Events & Conference calls
    • Rankia Funds Experience
    • RankiaPro Meetings
  • Podcast
  • MIFIDII Training

Follow us on social media

Linkedin Twitter Youtube Flickr

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe

Book now

Can ‘passive’ thematic strategies really provide expert stock selection?